Women with low response to IVF cycles
⥁ Management & better protocols
The incidence rate of poor responders (PORs) to stimulation in IVF cycles currently ranges from 7 to 24%. This rate is even higher in patients aged 38 years and older. The main causes are “ageing” of the ovaries and low ovarian reserve. The good news is that IVF can work for these patients too if the cause is found and treated with the most appropriate treatment.
Contents
- Definition of poor ovarian response
- Diagnosis
- Prognostic criteria
- Causes of poor ovarian response
- Negative effects
- Management & protocols
- Cost of treatment selection for women with poor response rates (PORs)
- Frequently asked questions
- Can I have sex as a low response to ovulation induction?
- Is the natural cycle a good option for women with low response?
- What if the number of eggs I produce is insufficient for IVF?
- Can women with poor response use supplements to improve IVF results?
- Growth hormone for women with poor response to IVF, yes or no?
- What is the best IVF protocol for women with poor response?
Definition of poor ovarian deviant
Poor ovarian response (POR) is the medical term used for women who are “poor responders” to IVF cycles. To consider a patient to be a poor responder, we will look at the following factors:
- Number of follicles in the ovary
- 7 or fewer follicles are observed via ultrasound in the ovaries.
- Number of oocytes recovered
- If only 3 have been recovered
- Estradiol levels (E2)
- A maximum E2 level of <500 pg/ml after an ovarian stimulation cycle.
Diagnosis
The term poor responder is usually used to describe a woman who has undergone at least 2 cycles of IVF stimulation that result in 3 or fewer follicles in each. These patients need ongoing emotional support during the IVF cycle (which we can provide) as the chances of their cycle being cancelled are higher for them. In these cases, they have no alternative but to restart a new stimulation cycle with a personalized protocol. It should also be stressed that ovarian age does not always match biological age.
Prognostic criteria
There are several tests that can help determine whether a woman has a low response before starting in order to tailor the stimulation protocol to the specific needs of the patient. There are several factors that indicate low ovarian response.
The most important ones are:
- Age
- Fewer than 7 primordial follicles observed in ultrasound
- Anti-slip hormone (AMH) below 1.2 ng/ml
- Basal FSH levels above 10 mIU/ml
- Diagnosis of POR in previous cycles
Causes of poor ovarian response
The following are the most common causes of poor ovarian response:
- Age: It is inversely proportional to the ovarian reserve. The older the woman, the more difficult it is to conceive due to reduced quantity/quality of eggs.
- Reduced ovarian size after surgery or endometriosis treatment
Negative effects
The ultimate goal of any IVF cycle is to induce the production of multiple eggs so that a large number can be retrieved and at least one of them is able to result in a viable embryo. This is precisely why poor response has a negative impact on the results of IVF. An insufficient number of eggs available for fertilisation reduces the chances of pregnancy and increases the likelihood of embryo transfer cancellation. In addition, POR often results in poor quality eggs.
Management & protocols
Women with a poor response to IVF have several options to succeed. Such as:
- Preparation with androgens
- Converting an IVF cycle to IUI
- IVF spreading protocol
- Oocyte aggregation & vitrification
- Egg donation
Preparation with androgens
After a poor response during an IVF cycle, it is possible for the patient to start a preparation with androgens in order to induce the production of multiple eggs. This can be done using transdermal testosterone or DHEA (oral dehydroepiandrosterone) replacement therapy. However, their effectiveness in cases of POR has not yet been proven.
Converting an IVF cycle to IUI
If one or two follicles are observed to develop via ultrasound, we may consider converting an IVF cycle to intrauterine insemination (IUI).
IVF flare protocol
In cases of poor response to IVF, a special treatment is designed to optimise the chances of success for these patients. The aim is, as always, to develop many eggs. An option widely used in these cases is the so-called flare protocol, also known as microflare, microdose flare, n or short protocol. In this type of ovarian stimulation, the GnRH agonist is started on day 2 of the same menstrual cycle in which egg retrieval takes place (i.e. before gonadotropin administration begins). In this way, we can take advantage of the initial secretion of FSH and LH release from the patient’s pituitary gland, which usually occurs in the first three days of agonist administration.
Embryo collection & vitrification
In order to maximise the number of embryos, several cycles of embryo accumulation can be performed. Embryo banking means that the embryos recovered with each cycle are frozen. They are then thawed and transported.
Vitrification is the extremely rapid cryopreservation of eggs, embryos and sperm, which prevents the formation of intracellular ice crystals
Egg donation
When multiple IVF cycles have been cancelled due to poor ovarian response, the best option for the patient is egg donation. Donors are young, healthy women who donate their eggs to another woman (the recipient). The donor’s eggs are fertilised using the husband’s sperm in the laboratory. When the patient is of advanced reproductive age, egg donation is the first-line treatment. It should be remembered that the quality of the eggs decreases as the woman grows older. So, for this reason, for a woman aged 43-44 years and older, the only option to become a mother may be to use eggs from a young donor.
Treatment costs for women with low response rates (PORs)
Another issue that arises in cases of poor ovarian response relates to the economic impact of multiple IVF cycles. This is why choosing the right treatment option is crucial to make it as affordable as possible.
Treatment costs for women with low response rates (PORs)
Another issue that arises in cases of poor ovarian response relates to the economic impact of multiple IVF cycles. This is why choosing the right treatment option is crucial to make it as affordable as possible.
Frequently asked questions
Is the natural cycle a good option for poor respondents?
In women with low response, there is medical evidence of similar live birth rates using high-dose ovarian stimulation versus natural cycle. This is probably because low-response women do not produce many eggs and high stimulation cannot deliver the extra. There are also reports that perhaps egg quality is better in a natural cycle.
What if the number of eggs I produce is insufficient for IVF?
In order to be able to fertilise more than one egg in the same IVF cycle, women’s ovaries are stimulated using fertility drugs. Often, due to a variety of reasons, the ovarian response of some patients is insufficient and the number of eggs collected is very low (below 3). In such cases, we can turn to the following strategies:
- cancel the cycle before egg retrieval and start a new stimulation cycle with a different stimulation protocol.
- freeze the eggs using the vitrification technique to collect a larger number of eggs in subsequent cycles.
- freeze the embryos using the embryo vitrification technique to collect a larger number of embryos cumulatively.
Can poor respondents use supplements to improve IVF results?
Many supplements are used in cases of poor ovarian response to increase the chances of pregnancy in these patients, such as DHEA, testosterone, CoQ10, human growth hormone (hGH), etc. However, in some cases they work, while in others they do not. Again, it depends on each woman’s response and the reason behind the POR in each case.
Growth hormone for poor responders to IVF, yes or no?
Some studies have concluded that the use of growth hormone (GH) can increase clinical pregnancy rates in women with poor response to IVF treatment. It can be added in the month before stimulation with gonadotropins or during the stimulation phase, as it can help increase follicle numbers. GH supplementation is patient dependent and is often applied in cases of women who have experienced previous IVF failure due to poor ovarian response despite maximum doses of gonadotropins.
What is the best IVF protocol for poor respondents?
Several studies have been carried out in an attempt to answer this question. However, no differences in pregnancy rates have been observed between different ovarian stimulation treatments. The truth is that each woman’s response is different, so are their needs. Hence the importance of individualizing each protocol in order to get the most out of it.